From left: Ezra Glenn as Union soldier George Bean, Kyler Evit as the MIA Redcoat, Gina Boyle as Hannah, Lucy Glazier as Dorcas Good, Lara Boyle as Emiline Dane, Barbara Mangum as Clairiana Bailey, Kristi Chase as Widow Rand, Derek Salvatore as the Reverend Phineas Howe, and Carl Spagnoli as Osgood Dane.

From left: John Huang as the unknown slave, Janet Wood-Spagnoli as the accused witch Sarah Wardwell, Jessica Hunt as Miss Clairiana Bailey, Kyler Evitt as the unknown Redcoat, Gina Boyle as Hannah, Barbara Mangum as Widow Rand, Lara Boyle as Emiline Dane, Lucy Glazier as Dorcas Good (accused of witchcraft at age 4 in Salem Villiage), in back: Carl Spagnoli as Osgood Dane, Isaac Gruman as William Farmileo, Anna Gruman as the young woman, Derek Salvatore as Reverend Howe of the First Baptist Church of Somerville.

Markus Nechay as Samuel Tufts in 2008